New York-style pizza · gyro toppings · Lombard
Slyce of NY
An oversized New York-style pie with gyro meat, peppers, onions and white-sauce drizzle. Order The 53rd to share, then decide who gets the last foldable slice.
Good for: share a big pizza
Research checked 2026-09-07 · 42 SPOTS editorial method
THE SHORT ANSWER
What to know before you go.
- Order first
- 18-inch The 53rd
- Starting order for two
- $26.99 before tax and tip
- Featured branch
- Lombard
- Halal information
- Certification listed
IF YOU GO FOR ONE THING
18-inch The 53rd
A repeat visitor specifically enjoyed The 53rd. Its current menu lists gyro meat, onions, green peppers and white sauce—a different topping combination from a standard pepperoni pie.
Direct diner reviews and current official menu; not a personal taste test. See the menu source ↗
Make a meal of it.
Other menu ideas: 18-inch Chicken Tikka Masala · 18-inch Hot Pepperoni Pie · Combo Chicken & Gyros (R)
REVIEW SHORTCUT
Slyce of NY Lombard: review notes.
We read a sample of diner reviews to help you decide what to order and what to check before visiting.
3 food-specific Google reviews read · checked 2026-09-07
Our pick: 18-inch The 53rd · Dish-specific diner feedback
What stands out
Two sampled diners liked The 53rd, and another praised the pizza and wings generally. Two of these otherwise positive food reviews criticized inattentive counter service.
Before you go
Service was the recurring caution in this small sample. One older review describes a BBQ version; the current menu and photo instead show gyro toppings and white sauce, which is the version described here.
A small sourced sample, not a score, a full consensus, or a personal visit by 42 SPOTS. Older observations may not reflect today.
FIND YOUR NEAREST TABLE
The featured location.
The dated Google rating and review count apply only to the featured branch. Other addresses are listed for convenience and do not inherit its rating. Menu prices, hours, halal sourcing and availability can differ by branch. The food and review notes above refer to Lombard, 219 E Roosevelt Rd.
Lombard · featured branch
219 E Roosevelt Rd, Lombard, IL 60148Menu, price example and review research on this page refer to this branch.
Publicly listed locations checked 2026-09-07. Confirm with the restaurant before travelling; this is not a live opening-status feed.
HALAL INFORMATION, WITH CONTEXT
Certification listed
HFSAA's Chicago certified-location directory lists Slyce of NY at 219 E Roosevelt Road, checked September 7, 2026. Confirm current certification details with the restaurant if needed.
We have not independently audited this kitchen or its suppliers. Confirm specific dishes, preparation and certification requirements with the restaurant.
View the evidence source ↗SOURCE NOTES
Sources checked for this profile.
These links let you verify the branch, menu, recommended dish, review shortcut and halal statement. They are evidence links—not endorsements of every claim on a third-party page.
- Official restaurant website ↗business and location context
- Published menu ↗dish and menu research
- Featured-branch Google listing ↗address, rating and review-count check
- Halal-information source ↗the exact claim summarized above
Know this place better?
Owners and diners can suggest a correction. Owners can also send a current menu and photos they authorize us to display. Inclusion is complimentary and is not a restaurant endorsement of 42 SPOTS.